Common core group inching along
The 21-member California State Content Standards Commission started the laborious process Tuesday of considering several dozen additions to the proposed national common-core English language arts standards.
Most of the additions are fine points – minor differences or omissions from California’s state standards that the commission’s staff are suggesting be added to bolster the “rigor” of common core. An example would be a sixth-grade requirement to analyze graphics and headlines in popular media — a standard found in California but not in common core. But in totality, the mound of changes will add complexity for teachers and could threaten the proposed common core standards’ readability and economy.
The writers of common core spent considerable time whittling down and weeding out some of what California may be putting back. That won’t become clear until the commission has waded through the proposed standards grade by grade, point by point. They still had 11 grades to go by adjournment on Tuesday.
Common core’s sponsors, the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers are permitting states to add 15 percent more standards to common core. But there’s no hard way of measuring that and no clear punishment for states that exceed the limit — other than docking points in the federal Race to the Top competition that California is unlikely to win anyway.
The commission will do an up or down vote on ELA today only after considering each proposed amendment. Then it will turn to common core math standards, which will be much more provocative, today and two days next week.






I have to admit that I’m feeling great frustration as I read this. It seems that, every time there might be an opportunity for California educators to collaborate with other states, we are once again being discouraged from working and focusing on student learning together. And this doesn’t address the additional cost associated with “California specific” textbooks. I am waiting on the math standards next….
Report this comment for abusive language, hate speech and profanity
Gabrielle, please don’t get frustrated. California educators can collaborate with other states — you don’t need to have common standards or common assessment for that. Otherwise you would never be able to collaborate with teachers in the neighboring school district (different textbooks & curricula) or other grade levels in your own school (different content). In fact, being the same as “everyone else” is not always an advantage. At least when it comes to the quality of standards, California has been an acclaimed leader for many years. Would you rather have us be as bad as “everyone else” has been until now?
Report this comment for abusive language, hate speech and profanity